We earn a commission from brands listed on this site. This influences the order and manner in which these listings are presented.
Advertising Disclosure
Last Updated: May 2024

Top Ohio Home Warranty Companies 2024
Protect yourself from unexpected repair costs

Don't get caught unprepared when a major appliance breaks. Find the best home warranty and keep your systems running year-round.

  • Security
  • Savings
  • Support
Top 3 Home Warranty Companies in Columbus
Great Value
Choice Home Warranty
Choice Home Warranty
exceptional
9.8
Special Offer: $75 off + 1 month free
Claim Offer
American Home Shield
American Home Shield
excellent
9.4
$50 off all plans
Claim Offer
First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty
excellent
9.1
Free instant quote
Claim Offer
Oops, something went wrong.
Looks like this page needs a second chance.Please try again later.

Our Best Home Warranty Provider

Oops, something went wrong.
Looks like this page needs a second chance.Please try again later.

We find the 10 best options, so you can make informed decisions on tons of products and services.

What Does Home Warranty Offer to a Homeowner?

You just purchased your dream house along with the all the perfect décor that turns your dream house into your dream home. It's been a few months and everything is unpacked and placed in its designated spot within your new home. So you turn your attention to rebuilding your savings account since it was depleted from the biggest and most important purchase of your life. However, within a few months of living in your dream home, you experience a costly unexpected expense when your heater blows out during the winter.

With a new mortgage payment and a limited amount in savings, you're looking at numerous financial options on how to pay for this unexpected expense. Fortunately, you purchased a home protection plan that will cover this expense as well as any major systems and appliances that may need repair or replacement in your home.

What Does a Home Warranty Include?

Home warranties typically include coverage the following major appliances and systems:

  • Central air conditioning systems
  • Central heating systems
  • Humidifiers
  • Interior electrical systems
  • Refrigerators
  • Ranges, ovens, and cooktops
  • Dishwashers
  • Built-in microwaves
  • Water heaters
  • Plumbing systems 
  • Garbage disposals
  • Washers and dryers
  • Garage door openers
  • Roof leaks

When Do You Need a Home Warranty?

Home warranties are offered to all homeowners whether they are new or existing. Typically, home warranty plans are offered to the home-buyer when they are purchasing a new home. However, if the buyer decides not to purchase home warranty insurance simultaneously with their home purchase, then they can secure a home protection plan at a later date. There is no time restriction as to when a homeowner can decide to purchase a warranty plan.

The Cost Involved With a Warranty for Your Home

Typically, a home warranty costs a couple hundred dollars, which can be paid in a lump sum amount during the purchase of a new home. This lump sum payment would be collected at the time closing costs are due for the newly purchased home. However, the seller, real estate agent or a family member or friend can purchase home warranties on behalf of a home-buyer. If a home appliance insurance claim is filed then the homeowner may be responsible for paying a service fee or deductible that typically ranges from $50 to $100. Please note, home warranty companies have different contract agreements therefore, fee amounts may vary.

Home Warranty Process

Filing a claim is a very simple process. Prior to filing your claim, review your insurance contract to verify the item that you need to repair or replace is covered under your plan. Once you verify this information, you'll complete the following steps:

  1. Contact your home warranty insurance company to file a claim.
  2. The warranty company will review their home warranty plans to verify that you have a plan that covers the item in question.
  3. The warranty company will schedule an appointment for you with a local contractor.
  4. The contractor will diagnosis the situation and makes a recommendation to repair or replace the item in question.
  5. Repairs and replacements will be carried out.
  6. You will pay a cost in the form of a service fee to the warranty company.
  7. Process is complete.

Conclusion

As there are many providers to choose from that have a variety of plan options; the best home warranty companies depend on how they can meet the needs of your home. The best way to select the right home protection plan for you is by doing your research on what each company has to offer with their plans. For instance, if you have a home with older appliances then you may be interested in locating a plan that has home appliance insurance. Want to learn more before choosing? Here are some tips and tricks to get you up-to-date.

Convinced? Check out our expert written reviews for information on the top providers for home warranty. Once you've selected the plan that best fits your needs, you'll join the many homeowners that have peace of mind because they are protected by one of the top home warranty companies. 

Our Top 3 Picks

  • 1
    Choice Home Warranty

    Choice Home Warranty

    • Best forHomeowners seeking affordable full-home coverage
    • Average annual premium$476–$660
    • Service requests24/7 online and by phone

    Choice Home Warranty is a budget-friendly option ideal for first-time homeowners. Choose between their customizable Basic Plan (12 items) and Total Plan (16 items) to receive up to $3,000 in coverage for each successful claim.

    Jake Hill, CEO of DebtHammer, highlights that Choice Home Warranty is also "especially helpful for owners of older homes" since they don't "deny coverage based on the age of your home's systems or appliances."

    Instead of varying their service fees, they only charge a flat $85 per claim. You also get your first month free if you're a new customer.

    Why we chose Choice Home Warranty: A stand-out from other services, Choice Home Warranty responds swiftly to queries and claims, delivers reliable customer service, and has affordable annual premiums.

    Our experience: We were impressed with Choice Home Warranty's fast turnaround time when submitting online and phone claims. The support specialists we worked with were knowledgeable and quickly provided helpful information.

    Pros
    • Low premiums
    • First month free
    • 24/7 online and phone home warranty resolutions
    Cons
    • Coverage limits of $250 to $3,000 per item
    • Not available in California
  • 2
    American Home Shield

    American Home Shield

    • Best forCustomizable plans
    • Average annual premium$500–$700
    • Service requests24/7 online and by phone

    Operating since 1971, American Home Shield is the largest and most established company in the US home warranty market, with over two million members.

    Tommy Gallagher, former investment banker and founder of Top Mobile Banks, was "impressed with the range of contractors they have available and the quality of service they provide."

    Choose from their three customizable plans—ShieldSilver, ShieldGold, and ShieldPlatinum. The ShieldSilver plan only covers 14 major systems, while the ShieldGold plan covers 23. 

    For additional perks, ShieldPlatinum comes with complete system and appliance coverage. This includes cost-saving add-ons like free HVAC tune-ups, unlimited A/C refrigerant, coverage for rooks leaks and code violations, and higher payout caps for repairs and replacements.

    Why we chose American Home Shield: They operate in 47 states and Washington DC, and you can customize your plan. American Home Shield automatically covers duplicate items, plus older items with rust or corrosion.

    Our experience: We found American Home Shield to be an excellent option for anyone seeking highly customizable plans and access to an extensive network of contractors. We could easily find a plan that suited our needs.

    Pros
    • Highly customizable plans
    • Includes undetectable pre-existing conditions
    • Covers older items, including rust and corrosion
    Cons
    • No guarantee for repair times
    • Not available in Alaska, New York City, or Hawaii
  • 3
    First American Home Warranty

    First American Home Warranty

    • Best forHigh payout caps
    • Average annual premium$360–$546
    • Service requests24/7 phone and online claims service No limit on number of service requests

    First American Home Warranty is an ideal choice for those seeking robust home protection for their systems and appliances. The company has been in business since 1984 and claims it's saved homeowners over $219 million in repair costs. 

    Coverage comes in the form of two basic plans and a premium plan. First American Home Warranty's best features include that they protect items regardless of age and replace faulty items with brand-new equivalents if they can't repair them.

    Why we chose First American Home Warranty: First American Home Warranty offers specialized plans for both real estate professionals and service providers. They also have 24/7 claims service, fully vetted tradespeople, and a transparent application process.

    Our experience: We liked First American Home Warranty's response times, which were significantly faster than other companies.

    Pros
    • 24/7 claims service
    • Fully vetted tradespeople
    • Low pricing and service fees
    Cons
    • Difficult to understand pricing breakdown without a personal quote
    • Their app is poorly rated

36,195 people

clicked on a home warranty provider this month

social-proof
ReviewsRead all reviews
Choice Home Warranty
Choice Home Warranty
Choice Home Warranty
Read Review
American Home Shield
American Home Shield
American Home Shield
Read Review
First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty
Read Review
Read all reviews